Straight Talk Advice

Oct 15, 2013

Divorced dad gets help winning back estranged daughter

Dear Straight Talk: My daughter, “Paige,” is 14. Her mother and I divorced four years ago and my ex has always said ugly things about me. Somehow Paige seemed to know these things weren’t true and we had a great relationship. Three months ago, Paige was very disrespectful to me over the phone and I cut off her cell phone when this behavior continued. During this time, I was pursuing a new custody agreement to prevent my ex from using the children to gouge me financially. Paige told me to stop pursing the new agreement or she’d never see me again. Now she won’t talk to me except to threaten to ask a judge to let her refuse visitations. What should I do? —Paige’s dad

Dear Paige’s Dad: Please study each word by Beau, Jennifer, and Bird. Advice on this topic doesn’t get better. As for Shelby’s advice: it’s a harsh delivery, but you can take it to the bank. 

Beau 18, Sacramento, Calif. Ask me a question

My parents divorced when I was one and I constantly went back and forth between homes. Children feel responsible for their parents’ divorce, and in a custody battle, think they must love one parent more than the other. Since your daughter can’t safely show affection for you around her mom, she sets up a defense mechanism that shuts you out. I’ve been there. My mom talked bad about my father and I agreed with her to be safe. Just remember, your daughter loves you. Give her some space while gently reassuring her that you’re there. Don’t talk bad about her mother, and above all, tell her/show her that you love her at every opportunity. My dad eventually became one of my closest friends. He gave me space and was there for me no matter what.

Shelby 16, Auburn, Calf. Ask me a question

Shutting off her cell over one rude conversation was about the stupidest thing you could do! A girl’s cell is her life! For starters, hook her phone back up.

Jennifer 14, Northern Calif, Ask me a question

She is going to want to see you. Let her cool off a couple weeks to where she starts feeling bad about what she said. Then turn on her cell and ask her to lunch. Ask how her life is going — and please, seem interested! Tell her you want her to be happy and to be with you. Ask what she likes to do, then do those things with her. (Hint: No 9000-mile hikes! Maybe bowling, movies, shopping, things a 14-year-old girl likes — and let her bring a friend.) When you’re winning her back, don’t have your significant other around; give her time just with you. Don’t speak badly about her mom, and don’t ask, “What’s your mom saying to you?” Finally, apologize. Don’t say, “I don’t know what I did to make you so mad.” That’s not an apology, that’s placing blame back on her.

Bird 17, High Falls, N.Y. Ask me a question

My father and I had the worst relationship. He favored my little brother who was easier to deal with than his 12-year-old daughter, who just wanted to be on the phone or go to the mall. I remember (with regrets) saying, “I wouldn’t care if my father died.” I despised his girlfriend and wouldn’t stay with him because of her. Now my dad accepts that and makes time just for me. Somehow our harsh conflict made me cherish him and we get along better than ever. He treats me like an adult and we talk on a mature level. Regarding the new custody agreement, if it is morally right, push on with it. Your daughter will eventually understand.

Comment Form

Straight Talk Advice readers are known for their frank and constructive posts that lead to insightful conversations that help many people! Please keep these guidelines in mind when posting:

  • Be constructive: Needlessly cruel or obscene comments will probably be removed. Be conscious of this so your point can be heard.
  • Be relevant: Spam or senseless character attacks irrelevant to the discussion will also probably be removed.

Happy posting!

Straight Talk Advice Recommends